The Messy Test Kitchen: Which common window cleaning method is most effective?

Apr 20, 2015Ariel
We test it so you don't have to! This week: which popular window cleaning method performs best?

 

The sun is shining, birds are chirping, flowers are blooming — time to throw open those windows and air out the house.

Those filthy, filthy windows. There must be some sign on them that only kids can see that says “wipe your grubby mitts here.”

Window cleaning is a chore that I don’t get around to all that often. I like to attribute it in part to perfectionism: Sometimes when you clean the windows, you find lint or smears when you’re done. That’s hardly satisfying. (Really, the problem is a mix of busyness and laziness.)

What’s the best way to clean windows without left-behind lint and streaks? Testing time!

 

We test it so you don't have to! This week: which popular window cleaning method performs best?

 

In the Messy Test Kitchen (and adjacent Messy Test Living Room) I tried out five popular methods. The Messy Test 3-Year-Old also experimented washing windows with a dried-out (clean) butt wipe. Don’t try that one at home.

We test it so you don't have to! This week: which popular window cleaning method performs best?

 

I used three or four spritzes of Windex with these four methods: newspaper, paper towels, squeegee, and a low-lint cotton (tea or floursack) towel. Finally, I tested the Norwex Microfiber Window Cloth, a chemical-free alternative.

I rated each method on a 1-to-5 scale (5 being best), considering how well they cleaned, whether they left behind lint or streaks, and anything else notable.

 

We test it so you don't have to! This week: which popular window cleaning method performs best?

 

Newspaper (& Windex)
Rating: 2.5
Were the windows clean? Yes. Were they streaky or linty? Not particularly. But if I have to clean the windows and then clean newspaper ink off my hands….

 

We test it so you don't have to! This week: which popular window cleaning method performs best?

 

Paper Towels (& Windex)
Rating: 4.5
My mom taught me to spray, scrub with two paper towels, and then buff with a third. In this test it worked perfectly; from time to time I’ve found a streak or bit of lint.
We test it so you don't have to! This week: which popular window cleaning method performs best?

 

Squeegee (& Windex)
Rating: 1
The squeegee could not remove sticky fingerprints; it left streaks and puddles of Windex that I needed the newspaper, towel, or paper towel to wipe up.

 

We test it so you don't have to! This week: which popular window cleaning method performs best?

 

Low-lint Towel (& Windex)
Rating: 4.5
Results were same as with paper towels.

 

We test it so you don't have to! This week: which popular window cleaning method performs best?

 

Norwex Microfiber Window Cloth
Rating: 5

I am not a Norwex user. (Thanks to my friendly neighbor who lets me borrow stuff.) Some people have concerns about Norwex products and whether they really can effectively kill bacteria without the use of chemicals. But when it comes to windows and mirrors, I don’t plan to make-out with them. I just want them to look clean.

I followed the instructions from this video (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gHQKdzSPM_0) and found it worked just as advertised. For a particularly grimy window you do need to have two different cloths — one of their all-purpose EnviroCloths, wet, to scrub the grime; and then their window cloth, dry, to buff and shine. But it did clean, lint- and streak-free.

THE RESULTS: 

Norwex Microfiber Window Cloth: 5
Paper Towels: 4.5
Low-lint Towels: 4.5
Newspaper: 2.5
Squeegee: 1

Squeegees are fun for 3-year-olds to play with. They can’t clean windows 3-year-olds have touched. Newspapers work but leave behind ink.

Was the difference between paper and cloth towels with Windex and the Norwex big enough to justify investing in Norwex? Only if you feel strongly about the occasional streak or lint particle, or getting away from cleaning chemicals.

Otherwise, it was pretty close to a draw. Just clean the windows and be done with it for … you know, however long.

 

Ariel-Signature

Let’s keep in touch:

Subscribe

Comments (8)

  • Ariel

    Chelc | Inside the Fox Den

    Jun 1, 2015 at 9:46 pm

    This is so helpful! Cleaning my windows was a big item on my spring cleaning list and now it’s June. I’ve never heard of the Norwex Microfiber Window Cloth though so I will have to check that out! Thanks for sharing at Merry Monday, hope to see you again next week!

  • Ariel

    Maureen Otremba

    May 5, 2015 at 6:14 pm

    The trick I learned from my mom is to wash windows with Windex (or an environmentally friendly cleaner containing vinegar) and wipe with COFFEE FILTERS. I know it sounds odd, but it really works, leaves no streaks, and there is no ink residue. And no lint at all.

  • Ariel

    Mari Hyatt

    May 5, 2015 at 4:02 pm

    I probably shouldn’t admit this, but I’ve never cleaned the windows in the three years we’ve lived in our house. We’re getting ready to sell it now, so this advice is nice.

  • Ariel

    Sara Johnson

    May 5, 2015 at 3:30 pm

    Thank you for this helpful information! I was searching on Pinterest for the best solution for cleaning my windows and came across this. I’m invited to a Norwex party in two weeks, now I know what to get. And in the meantime I’ll keep using paper towels.

  • Ariel

    KC

    Apr 29, 2015 at 4:52 am

    Two other benefits that you didn’t mention about using Norwex cloths: 1. You only buy the cloths once but you have to keep buying Windex and paper towels as you run out. 2. It’s safe to let your little ones clean with a Norwex cloth and they LOVE doing it! Mine started when they were 3 and 5, and they still enjoy helping two years later. :)

  • Ariel

    Dawn

    Apr 22, 2015 at 11:15 am

    This is really helpful, I usually use Norwex cloths because I have them, but sometimes if I have a particularly dirty window, it is nice to have a disposable option like paper towels so I don’t have to get my cloths dirty ;) And, I think once you use the Norwex cloths on mirrors, which show lint a little more than windows, you’ll never go back!

  • Ariel

    Anna Holland

    Apr 20, 2015 at 6:28 pm

    This is interesting, I always thought newspaper was supposed to be the best but like you, think it is a pain how the ink gets on your hands and it doesn’t scrunch up very nice. I’m going to try paper towels next time.

  • Ariel

    Sai Collins

    Apr 20, 2015 at 6:26 pm

    This is SO helpful, thank you! I always like when what our moms and grand moms taught us wins out :)

What do you think? Please join in!

Prev Post Next Post